So I got my hands on the spec script for Elementary - the version written in 2000 for CBS, which was passed on. I honestly don't know if the new pilot has anything to do with this one. The only difference 2012 is set in New York City and 2000 is set in San Francisco. And who knows if they are using ANYTHING from it for the new one. I hope they don't.
Both are obviously American and therein lies the problem, above all. Well, the other problem is I unfortunately had Benedict and Martin's voices in my head as I read. Not a bad thing at all, but I was trying to read it objectively and failed on that point.
Oh, another problem: it had a bad plot! It was so obviously written by an American, using American style and American plot twists and American procedural crime drama formats. Ugh. I know this 2012 Elementary will be exactly the same way. And it's so upsetting. I don't understand why it's being done other to capitalise on the BBC version which literally makes no sense as there is NO WAY you can ever surpass anything made by British people.
It's going to be just another procedural crime drama featuring a super special snowflake with super special skills. Monk, Psych, Unforgettable, House (okay not police, but definitely procedural snowflake). All one word titles to project just HOW SPECIAL they are.
I want the script for the new Elementary to read. I want to know just how much it will suck.
There are rumours that Watson might be female. Oh, how SURPRISING. The fandom will automatically ship Sherlock and any other male character so there's no point making Watson a woman. Also, it definitely does change the balance of their relationship, having a female sidekick. I can only imagine what some of my more feminist friends will rant about regarding that. It matters not to me, as I've mentioned, because nothing and no one could surpass my Sherlock (oh, Benedict, you are my one and only, sorry Jeremy). But I will enjoy the wankery.